There won’t be a press conference announcing that democracy has ended in America and there won’t be tanks rolling through the streets or foreign invaders telling us to shelter in place over loudspeakers.
It won’t be that dramatic when our democracy slips away.
And in fact it’s already doing so, week by week under the Trump regime. As Steven Levitsky, Lucan Way and Daniel Ziblatt explain in a guest essay in The New York Times: “today’s autocrats convert public institutions into political weapons, using law enforcement, tax and regulatory agencies to punish opponents and bully the media and civil society onto the sidelines.”
The authors point out that a fundamental right in a democracy is the right to oppose the government.
“Under authoritarianism, by contrast, opposition comes with a price. Citizens and organizations that run afoul of the government become targets of a range of punitive measures: Politicians may be investigated and prosecuted on baseless or petty charges, media outlets may be hit with frivolous defamation suits or adverse regulatory rulings, businesses may face tax audits or be denied critical contracts or licenses, universities and other civic institutions may lose essential funding or tax-exempt status, and journalists, activists and other critics may be harassed, threatened or physically attacked by government supporters.”
The authors go on to document that all of these things are happening under the Trump administration.
“The administration’s authoritarian offensive has had a clear impact. It has changed how Americans behave, forcing them to think twice about engaging in what should be constitutionally protected opposition. Consequently, many of the politicians and societal organizations that should serve as watchdogs and checks on the executive are silencing themselves or retreating to the sidelines.”
The authors continue:
“So far, American society’s response to this authoritarian offensive has been underwhelming — alarmingly so….The acquiescence of our most prominent civic leaders sends a profoundly demoralizing message to society. It tells Americans that democracy is not worth defending — or that resistance is futile. If America’s most privileged individuals and organizations are unwilling or unable to defend democracy, what are ordinary citizens supposed to do?”
But the authors end on a hopeful note.
“There are signs of an awakening. Harvard has refused to acquiesce to administration demands that would undermine academic freedom, Microsoft dropped a law firm that settled with the administration and hired one that defied it, and a new law firm based in Washington, D.C., announced plans to represent those wrongfully targeted by the government. When the most influential members of civil society fight back, it provides political cover for others. It also galvanizes ordinary citizens to join the fight.”
Finally, there is this:
“America’s slide into authoritarianism is reversible. But no one has ever defeated autocracy from the sidelines.”
HEADLINES:
India, Pakistan Agree to Cease-Fire After U.S.-Mediated Talks (WSJ)
Federal judge in Vermont orders immediate release of Tufts University student Rümeysa Öztürk after 6 weeks in detention (CNN)
Trump named Fox News host Jeanine Pirro, a former county prosecutor and elected judge, as his pick to be the top federal prosecutor for the nation’s capital after dropping his original nominee. [AP]
Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem openly flouted a Supreme Court order to facilitate the return of Kilmar Abrego Garcia to the U.S., insisting that there is "no scenario" in which the Maryland man will be in the country again. [HuffPost]
Ahead of trade talks, Trump says an 80% tariff on China 'seems right' (NPR)
Detroit automakers fuming after Trump’s first trade deal gives preferential treatment to imported U.K. cars over their own (Fortune)
Trump’s Supposed U.K. Trade Deal Gets Trashed by Surprising Person (TNR)
Poll shows big problem for Trump’s trade deal: It’s Trump (Politico)
Up to 1,000 transgender troops are being moved out of the military in new Pentagon order (AP)
How Will We Know When We Have Lost Our Democracy? (NYT)
Pope Leo Warns Against Spread of ‘De Facto Atheism’ (WSJ)
Pope Leo's stance on key issues, from climate change to LGBTQ+ rights to U.S. politics (NPR)
An American Pope Emerges as a Potential Contrast to Trump on the World Stage (NYT)
Things Are About to Get Complicated for the Fed (Bloomberg)
Mexico sues Google over changing Gulf of Mexico’s name for US users (Guardian)
Fog of war thickens as India and Pakistan trade blame and accusations (WP)
Trump floats raising taxes on the rich to pay for his sweeping tax and spending cuts package (CNN)
Uproar over surgeon general pick exposes MAHA factions among RFK Jr. allies (WP)
US senator introduces bill calling for location-tracking on AI chips to limit China access (Reuters)
AI is not your friend (Atlantic)
Study: Most Millennials Will Never Own Swanky Undersea Apartment Where Fish Swim Past Windows (The Onion)