The game clock controversy surrounding the Michigan football team’s last-second victory on Saturday highlights a deeper problem. Millions of people watching the game on television assumed Michigan had lost when the “clock” they saw showed 0.00 time remaining.
But the official time-keeper said that actually a fraction of a second of playing time did remain and Michigan’s quarterback made the most of it, hurling a dramatic 47-yard touchdown pass to gain a one-point victory over Western Michigan, 13-12.
So the issue here is not the outcome; Michigan won the game fair and square.
The problem is that millions of people saw what they assumed was the official clock expire on the second-to-last play, which was an incomplete pass. But it turns out that that clock wasn’t accurate.
We’ve been dealing with the implications of millions of people drawing conclusions from what they think they see on video for decades. And now that essentially everyone has a powerful camera on their cellphone, the problem is reaching dangerous proportions.
Most sports now have a video review feature to try and ensure that official get their calls right. These increasingly involve multiple views from multiple angles in an effort to do so. As players and fans get used to the new replay technologies, everyone waits for the ruling and most people accept it, one way or the other.
Live television coverage of news events has no such capability. It’s still in its dinosaur stage where one view suits all purposes, with some exceptions. So masses of people are forming opinions based on what they think they see there, or, perhaps worse, from amateur videos that surface online.
That is potentially dangerous when it comes to situations more critical than who wins a football game.
HEADLINES:
Canadian tariffs on U.S. milk, perfume, golf clubs and other goods take effect as trade war grinds on (CBS)
Mass deportations and separate schools for refugees: The far-right AfD’s vision for Germany (CNN)
German nationalists’ big win sounds alarm for mainstream politicians in Europe (WP)
After Far-Right Triumph, Merz Faces Narrow Path to Save His Government (WSJ)
Houthis attack Saudi Arabia and wound dozens in major expansion of war in the Middle East (Independent)
Israeli airstrikes on a village in southern Lebanon kill 12 people, including 2 children (AP)
Iran war drives $100 billion in extra energy costs for U.S. consumers (Axios)
Iran warns US energy assets in Gulf are vulnerable after latest clashes (Reuters)
Speech in China is in the deep freeze (Economist)
China readies for humanoid robot wars. (Reuters)
U.S. exploring Russia-Ukraine winter de-escalation steps (Axios)
25 years after Sept. 11 attacks, Taliban rules Afghanistan again, but now with $7 billion in U.S. firepower (CBS)
New Mexico Democrats push back over Trump posts about renaming the state ‘New America’ (NBC)
As the unofficial start of the campaign sprint kicks off on Labor Day, President Donald Trump’s deep unpopularity is imperiling Republican chances of maintaining their narrow majorities in Congress with just two months before November’s midterm elections. (Reuters)
Maria Bartiromo’s Downfall at an Increasingly Cautious Fox News (NYT)
Trump pledged to lower prices in eight areas. Have they risen or fallen? (WP)
Trump says he’s made ‘Hundreds of Billions of Dollars on Stocks’ for the U.S., in stream of AI posts (CNBC)
The poorest in the US can’t find housing even as low-income units sit empty (AP)
The Burning Man Crowd Is Getting Old (NYT)
Gloria Steinem Gave It All (New Yorker)
Michigan’s last-gasp miracle by Bryce Underwood saves Whittingham debut from disaster (Athletic)
AI Is Already Changing What It Means to Be Human (Atlantic)
UN rights chief warns how AI could pose ‘existential risk to humanity’ (EuroNews)
Research acceleration: The view inside OpenAI (OpenAI)