Tuesday, March 21, 2023

Ring of Truth

During my recent trip to Arizona, my sister told me a story about an incident that happened when I was in kindergarten. Apparently, she and I were sitting on our front porch when I spotted a girl I liked from my class walking toward our house on the sidewalk.

As the girl drew near, I grabbed a newspaper, held it up and pretended to read it.

That happened today?” I called out loudly. “How interesting!”

***

Most of the time, I’m the oldest one in the room, so when it comes to memories, mine reach back the furthest. So it is a refreshing experience whenever I get to hang out with my sisters, who remember things that I don’t.

It is also nice to be just a character in the memory of others as opposed to the being the family patrician and sole custodian of the now-distant past.

I was almost 30 when my first child was born, and almost 60 when my first grandchild was born. That’s a lot of rings on the tree for me to try and recall when my descendants ask me specific questions about the past.

Besides, the way I tell a tale is not necessarily more accurate than anyone else, plus the more distant in the past an event occurred, the more our individual versions are likely to diverge, which brings me to the phenomenon of memory consensus.

Within families, communities, countries, cultures — even on a species level — we ultimately tend to reach some sort of consensus about the past, though historians, ideologues, contrarians and poets continue to debate and revise that consensus as new evidence emerges.

And as much as I enjoy telling my descendants stories from the past, I’m acutely aware from my journalism career that for a more well-rounded narrative, other sources ought to be interviewed. My version is only that — mine.

A joint family memoir would no doubt do a better job. As the saying goes, ‘there’s your version, my version and then there’s the truth and no one is lying.’

As for the story of the girl and the newspaper at the top of this essay, I had no memory of it until my sister told me about it last week.

That said, it has the ring of truth.

LINKS:

 

No comments: